14/03/2008

The past few episodes have been a bit of a relative slump for this season. While the first few installments really seemed to start off with a bang, the previous two weeks have seemed to be…well…filler. Ji Yeon, unfortunately, continues that tradition.
In the “main” storyline, Sun convinces Jin that they should not leave the island, and they decide to join in Locke’s camp. Juliet pleads with Sun to leave the island for the sake of her baby…and finally reveals the secret of Sun’s affair to her husband. This results in them staying in Camp Jack. And then they all make up and everyone’s okay. So the characters are in the exact same place as they were when they began the episode. Zero character development = filler.
Elsewhere, Desmond and Sayid are still stuck on the freighter. They receive a note from the mysterious mole on the boat, telling them not to trust the captain. They meet said captain, who reveals that the boat is the property of one Charles Widmore, the father of Des’ beloved Penny. Some chick commits suicide. The captive duo are then lead to their new, roach-infested, blood-stained quarters. This lead to my favorite moment of the episode…the return of Michael, in the guise of janitor Kevin Johnson. I love the barely contained surprise, and somewhat rage, between the characters.
Then, in the flashbacks and flashforwards, we discovered that Sun had a baby girl, named Ji Yeon. Somewhere however, apparently between the “rescue” and the baby’s birth, Jin met some kind of untimely end.
And that’s really it. There weren’t any major revelations…we already knew the freighter was Widmore’s boat, and that they were not really there to rescue the castaways. We already knew that there was wreckage of Oceanic 815 that has been recovered. Granted, these revelations were made to new characters, and that new information has new meaning for them. But, since the series has a finite end in sight, this show has to continue to dish out answers and continue to push the narrative forward. This episode did neither of those things.
Episode grade: C+
UPDATE
So when I was watching the show, I saw all of the dates on the tombstone except for the important one, I guess. Take a look at this picture…especially the date on the far right.
Jin’s date of death is actually listed as 2004-9-22…which, for us Americans who don’t read dates like everyone else in the world, translates to September 22, 2004. Sound familiar? That’s the date of the Oceanic 815 crash.
Jin is not one of the Oceanic 6. So now I’m confused…it was teased that we would know the identities of all the Oceanic 6…but Jin seems to have never left the island. Did they consider little prenatal Ji Yeon to be one of the survivors, too?
Now that we have something to talk about, I may have to bump my review up to a B.
6 Responses to: UPDATED - Lost - Review - Season 4, Episode 7 (s04e07)
Michael
March 14th, 2008 at 9:29 am
I have to take issue with your review, my friend.
First - Sun and Jin are not in the same place they were before the episode happened. Sun did not truly believe Juliet before this episode - and now she knows for sure that if she does not get off that island she will die.
We learned that she does, indeed, get off the island. In fact, we now know who all of the “Oceanic 6″ are…we know that none of the other 6 (besides Hurley) care enough about Sun to even come see the baby.
Why is that?
We learn that Jin is either dead, or at least Hurley and Sun think he’s dead (I’m still hoping that somehow he’s not actually dead).
For that matter, we know that Sun’s baby is going to be born - another revelation that we didn’t know about.
In the other story, we finally get confirmation that Michael is the mole on the boat (something I think most of us assumed from the beginning). We finally met the Captain (which I found disappointing, but at least we’ve seen the character established).
So, I don’t really feel like this episode was filler…however…I was severely unhappy with the combination of flash backs and flash forwards used in a way to “trick” us into thinking Jin was safely off the island.
Even though Lost is all about pulling the rug out from under us, I have never been quite as dissatisfied or felt as cheated, as I did watching this episode.
Scott
March 14th, 2008 at 10:00 am
I agree with Michael about it not being filler. I loved the episode.
Drew
March 14th, 2008 at 10:17 am
So basically it served to strengthen her resolve to leave the island. It further solidified a decision that she had already made. Now she REALLY believes Juliet instead of just kinda believing her before. I don’t think that’s enough to constitute any kind of real growth.
I understand there were some revelations in some of the other subplots, but…I guess my problem is that they had a Jin/Sun story that they wanted to tell in the flashforward, so they HAD to find something to do with them on the island, so they sent their island story around in a circle for the episode. I wish they could have done something more substantial with them on the island.
Michael
March 14th, 2008 at 10:42 am
@Drew
I think revealing the affair that Sun had, and seeing that Jin has grown so much as a person on the island that he can find it within himself to forgive her - something he NEVER would have done before being lost - is very significant character growth.
I just don’t think you like Sun and Jin all that much.
Scott
March 17th, 2008 at 10:11 am
Couldn’t Aaron be considered one of the oceanic 6?
Ed
March 17th, 2008 at 4:27 pm
They have revealled all the Oceanic 6:
Jack
Kate
Hurley
Sun
Sayid
Aaron
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Search
Categories
Blogs We Like
Design Disease